Don’t Let the Door Hit You on the Way Out! Knowing When It’s Time to Go.

Andy Porter Andy Porter, Career Paths, Employee Relations, Succession Planning

Recently my wife and I were looking over some potential mutual fund investments and while most of it was incredibly boring to me I was fascinated by one thing. There was a page that listed all the fund managers and their years of experience – 20 years, 25 years and even 38 years doing the same work. While I suppose this is meant to give me confidence, it also made me wonder. How long is too long to stay in a particular role? A profession? Am I all of a sudden going to wake up at 60 and still be trying to convince people that feedback is important, but the performance review form itself is not?  When is the right time to move on?

Do_me_a_favre_and_retire_already_tshirt-p235500764273251916ygbh_400 Off the top of my head, I could think of a few people who hung around too long: The Rolling Stones, Brett Favre and Joe Paterno. These guys were all great in their time but they tarnished their legacies by not being able to let go and move on and frankly are now just sad. On the other hand, you’ve got guys like Barry Sanders, Jerry Sloan and Led Zeppelin lead singer, Robert Plant, who knew when it was time to walk away or, in Plant’s case, knew better than to try and re-live the past. Plant turned down a $200M offer to go on tour because he knew it could never be the same and would only lead to disappointment. Sanders walked away while he was still the top running back in the NFL.

So what does this mean for people like us who are responsible for talent in our organizations? It means understanding the different types of roles that tend to emerge in organizations and figuring out where it’s okay to have a long term employee and where it’s not okay. Like these classic types:

    • The Comforters – these are the guys who show up on the pages of mutual fund prospectuses. Lots of experience, gray hair and looking very successful. And you know what? That’s exactly who I want to see in a business where experience and relationships matter. It makes me feel like I’m in good hands.


    • The Rocks – they’re not flashy or fancy but they get the job done. The profession doesn’t change all that much but having a high level of proficiency makes our organizations run smoother. Think of these as “career level” roles rather than training ground roles.


    • Fat and Happy – these roles? No one’s giving these up. Perks galore – big budgets, nice office, lots of direct reports, and lots of power. More to the point – there’s no longer any distinction between themselves and their roles. Look at all the guys above who couldn’t walk away. So they stay in their roles and flex their muscles and generally make peoples’ lives miserable.


  • The Blockers – this is the classic feeder role. That is until the blocker arrived, stays too long and prevents up and coming talent from gaining valuable experience and moving up in the organization. These guys are different from the fat and happy crew – maybe they changed their minds about the track they want to be on but don’t see an easy transition out. Law firms actually handle these situations quite well.  If you don’t want to be on the partner track, they let you look for a new job and transition out of the firm.

Sometimes you want for lifers, sometimes you don’t. But as long as you know when it makes sense for the organization – then you’re good. And sure, this isn’t an easy issue to deal with especially since we’re dealing with people’s lives.  But that doesn’t mean we should stop asking the tough questions about what’s best for our organizations.